Ready for Adoption?
Adoption Network Law Center
Adoption Network Law Center
Want to Adopt? Click here.
Click here to be helped in California!
Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click here.
Adoption Network Law Center
Crisis Pregnancy Blog

05/09/06

Abortion vs. adoption

Posted by : Heather Lowe in Crisis Pregnancy Blog at 07:04 am , 810 words, 244 views  
Categories: Stories and situations, Issues/debate
For the next month I’ll be in the midst of relocating for a new job, which means I'm not able to post as much as I’d like. To help kick start me into writing more, I recently asked the ladies over at the Unplanned Pregnancy forum for topics they’d like me to address.

Here’s the first request, from Jenna:
"I've recently become interested in how many first parents were told to abort by either a family member or the father of the child, and the reasons as to why they did not do it."


I don’t have any solid statistics here, although a quick web search has suggested that family opinions are the factor with the single strongest impact on how a pregnant woman decides to handle her unplanned pregnancy.

I do know that it is very common for family members and the father of the child to register a strong opinion, either for abortion, adoption or parenting. Very few people seem to be able to stand back and say, "Do what you think is best."

SPONSOR
  Adopt in California

I also know that the positions taken by loved ones can often change during the course of the pregnancy and immediately after.

In my case, because I was not in a relationship with the father of my child, I initially thought of abortion. I made two appointments, but could not go through with them. (I'm not opposed to abortion, but once I was faced with it, I felt like it was something I personally wanted to avoid. I cancelled my appointment twice.)

It was just a subtle feeling I had, that I ought to carry this child and allow him to be born. Beyond that, I wasn't sure what I should do, but I knew I wanted to continue my pregnancy.

I was leaning strongly toward parenting at that point, despite being told by my father that he thought abortion was the smart thing to do. (He now regrets this very deeply. At the hospital, he broke down in tears and asked me to forgive him for how wrong he had been.)

My mother did not think I should abort, but thought adoption was the answer. Again, her opinion on that has changed now that she’s actually had to live with adoption.

My older sister was willing to go with me to the abortion procedure, but didn’t voice much of an opinion about it. She too thought adoption was the best answer.

As for the father of my baby, he did not tell me what to do, but he was leaving the country to serve in the Peace Corps for two years, and wasn’t going to be able to help with daycare expenses or be present for the first two years of our son’s life. So while he didn’t attempt to persuade me into any certain decision, his choices and actions served as another type of pressure. He did seem to think adoption was the answer, and probably still does. He’s also said he is very glad I did not abort our child.

I think the reason I was able to stand up to pressure about abortion (which in my case was far less serious than the heavier pressures toward adoption) is that many people are willing to get behind a person who feels abortion is wrong for them. But very few people feel adoption is a bad thing to do. Quite the opposite, in fact—-most people see adoption as a win-win situation in which the expectant parents get to be free of parenthood while deserving infertile couples get to achieve their dream of having a family. (It’s only after you actually surrender a child that you are seen as a heartless abandoner by some.)

In the end, I think pressures to abort are generally less ongoing and persistent than pressures to choose adoption. People may tell you to abort, and harrass you to do so, but when you don’t, they usually accept your decision and move on. (After a certain time period, they have to.) With adoption (or parenting), they have at least nine full months to talk you into it.

When you abort, it is more of a private decision, and no one gains anything much from it. But when you consider adoption, a whole new family is going to possibly benefit. That means you now have many extra people registering an opinion—-social workers, agency staff, lawyers, facilitators, and hopeful adoptive couples. Most of these people will obviously have a bias as to what you should do. It's a logical and understandable bias, but still a bias.

Well, I hope other birthmoms will chime in here and answer Jenna's question. Were you told to have an abortion, and if so, how did you successfully resist the idea?

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: mom2be [Member] Email
I am an expectant mother who was constantly and consistently pressured by every single person I talked to about my pregnancy to have an abortion.... friends, family, boyfriend and his family, etc. I have been pro-life for as long as I've known about abortion, but it seems these days that everyone is pro-choice, especially when it comes to an unplanned teen pregnancy. It took a lot of strength of character, willpower and faith to avoid going through with it after threats, interventions and bribes. It was something I knew I couldn't do in my heart, and I knew I had to do what was best for ME. I knew it would be something I regretted throughout my life, and I didn't want to be a hypocrite or not put what I preached into action. It was the hardest thing I ever did, but the best thing. After resisting that, when people try to persuade me to parent or make an adoption plan, I know I have the strength in me to make my own choice, the decision that I know is best in my heart.
PermalinkPermalink 05/09/06 @ 10:25
Comment from: Maybug [Member] Email
My experience is probably going to throw your hypthosis out the window--in my case, it was my doctor that encouraged me to choose abortion rather than birthing the child. Yep--you can pick up your chin from the floor now. I was sixteen years old, daughter of a divorced, unemployed, poor woman living on welfare. I went to my doctor appointment knowing I was pregnant. However, my mother thought I was there for a different reason. My mother never knew I was pregnant. My doctor simply handed me information on where and how to get an abortion and said I needed to do it soon because if I waited another week, I would have to stay overnight for the procedure. As a timid 16-yr-old, I did what my doctor said. I had an abortion, didn't tell anybody, and have had to live with that decision my entire life. I am now 36 years old. Do I regret it? Yes. Did I have any alternatives? At the time, I didn't think I did. Now, as an adult, looking back, I know that I did. Today, I have been married 16 years, have three children, a Master's Degree, and live a modest lifestyle. I feel that the doctor took my life and my unborn child's life into his hands simply because I was a poor, welfare child. Instead, he should have called my mother and/or contacted social services to enlist help for me. I have since had two miscarriages, a common side effect from undergoing an abortion. No one told me the emotional side effects that would haunt me my entire life.
PermalinkPermalink 05/09/06 @ 12:09
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
Mom2Be,
I'm so glad for you!
Yes, it is very hard to carry your baby when people are on your case to have an abortion.

Glad your strength has carried over from that first decision to the next. Some women get exhausted fighting the first battle and lose strength for the second.

- Heather
PermalinkPermalink 05/09/06 @ 12:35
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
Maybug,

I am so sorry that this happened to you.

I do feel it's important for people to realize there are ongoing lifelong effects from all three decisions: abortion, adoption or parenting. All of them change you forever.

- Heather
PermalinkPermalink 05/09/06 @ 12:36
Comment from: merrill1277 [Member] Email
Heather you wrote: "In the end, I think pressures to abort are generally less ongoing and persistent than pressures to choose adoption." This was true in my case in the late 1970's. It was only two people, my best friend at the time, and my boyfriend, who suggested abortion. On the other hand, it was my mother, her priest, Catholic Charities, the doctor and several others who heavily pushed adoption. I wanted to keep my baby. Being unwed, lacking in resources and fired from my clerical job when I began to show...I can go on but will stop for brevity here...everything seemed to stack up against me. The doctor knew the couple who later adopted my newborn. Once he got involved and got lawyers involved (pre-birth), I felt as though there was no way out. I was also unexpectedly put out (drugged) for 8 hours during and after the birth. This is only a bare sketch of everything...but it all stacked heavily on the side of adoption, zero support given to parent. I realize this varies for others in terms of whether family members and others involved will support them or manipulate them, and in which direction.
PermalinkPermalink 05/09/06 @ 20:22
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Categories

Misc

Subscribe to Crisis Pregnancy Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 132