Adoption Network Law Center Adoption Network Law Center Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click here.
Adoption Network Law Center
Crisis Pregnancy Blog

05/14/06

A Mother's Day story

Posted by : Heather Lowe in Crisis Pregnancy Blog at 12:34 pm , 560 words, 63 views  
Categories: Stories and situations, Internet resources

Happy Mother's Day to all mothers of every kind. On this holiday, I want to send my sincere good wishes to all the expectant mothers now going through an unplanned pregnancy. Please celebrate today, and do something nice for yourself. You are a mother, and always will be, no matter what your ultimate decision.

Today also seems like the right occasion to share a candid and inspirational story I came across. It's called "Parenting on a Dare: My Decision to Accept Teen Motherhood."

The author, Amy Benfer, got pregnant at age 16, and made the unlikely decision to parent (with a lot of support from her own parents in the first couple of years). She's now a successful writer, and her daughter is 14 years old. Despite the conventional wisdom that any child of a teen mother would always be better off being raised by older, married parents, Amy's daughter does not seem to have suffered from her young mother's decision to preserve their little family.

What I like most about this article is that it shows just how easy it is to second-guess ourselves...especially with a decision as big as abortion, adoption or parenting. In fact, the road to any pregnancy/parenting decision is paved with endless "what-ifs." What if I keep my baby--will he/she be happy and well-adjusted, or will I screw up somehow and cause lasting damage? Will my child be better off with another family, or would he/she prefer to stay in ours? What will cause the least amount of pain for everyone involved? How can I ever really know?

In the article, Benfer is refreshingly honest about her own choice and about what her daughter has lost and gained from her decision. I especially love this passage, about the adoptive family that might have been:
"I am in the strange situation of having known the couple who wanted to raise my child if I had not chosen to do so. I selected them, I sat in their living room, I toured the house and talked with them about their philosophy of child rearing. We haven't spoken in 15 years, but I've heard enough to have an idea of where they are now. I know that in her parallel life, my child would have grown up the daughter of a social worker and a real estate agent in the Northwest. She would live in a four-bedroom house; she would have a summer cottage in the mountains. She would have been allowed to have a dog, and it's likely she'd have a brother and a sister. She wouldn't have seen as much of the world. She may have grown up to be more like the girl I was at her age, a suburban teenager longing for adventure and danger and a more exciting life. She would have been more stable.

I don't know that girl. She isn't my daughter."

SPONSOR
  Adopt in California

For those of us who have already experienced or are now facing unplanned pregnancies, it's tempting to imagine parallel lives for our children, and wonder what might have been. Such daydreams and regrets are probably even beneficial for our mental health. All I know is, Amy Benfer was a mother from the time she got pregnant. Even if she had gone through with the adoption, she could never have erased her motherhood.

Have a happy Mother's Day, everyone!







Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: marymartha [Member] Email
Just one comment :-) A teen isn't making the "unlikely decision to parent." The majority of placements don't come from teens but older more mature women who truly realize what comes with parenting. I've talked to DOZENS of teens who are pregnant while they are in the decision making process and I always hear the same point from them, "I just want someone to love me." Not a very good reason to parent when you can't even take care of yourself yet.
PermalinkPermalink 05/14/06 @ 15:21
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
I am not in a place to know if the majority of placements now come from teens or not. I have heard others say that too. However, I do know that even more "mature" women who may realize what parenting is about still rarely have much of an idea as to how losing a child to adoption may feel later. Nor do they have a clue as to potential harm to their children by relinquishing them. Lastly, they do not understand the impact on losing a sibling for their other children.

Personally, I am tired of hearing all the reasons that so many people believe that relinquishing a child to adoption is "better" for a pregnant woman (or her child) than parenting. Sometimes it might be, but, not always. Parenting at any age has its pros and cons - there are some advantages to parenting at a young age for a woman AND her child.

My daughter was raised by a teen mom too (me)and I do not believe that she was adversely impacted by. Age should not be the only factor considered in determining whether a woman should parent or not.

PermalinkPermalink 05/14/06 @ 16:43
Comment from: marymartha [Member] Email
There are some VERY valid reasons that relinquishing is sometimes better for a child than parenting by the bio parents. I think the vast majority of the time the child is better wit her bio parents, but there is some validity for adoption. You cannot say all adoption is bad and all parenting is good. There are instances where adoption is "better" for the child and it takes a very strong unselfish woman to realize that.
I think teenage parenting can be done successfully, however I wish more teens would consider adoption. I have a cousin who had her first child two weeks shy of fourteen. and had four by the age of twenty. A thirteen year old has no business under ANY circumstances parenting a child. So while I don't think age should be the only factor, it should be a factor.
PermalinkPermalink 05/14/06 @ 18:28
Comment from: Ellen Rardin [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
I liked the article. We all know people who have chosen parenting over adoption where their choice didn't work out very well for the child. On the other hand,can we assume that things always work out for the child with the adoptive parents? People who adopt are pretty much like everyone else. There are great ones,adequate ones,and lousy ones. Some "stable,older" adoptive parents go on to put their children thru messy divorces/custody battles,develop substance abuse problems or develop seious mental health issues. My point is-there are simply is no way we can always make predictive statements about the future.
PermalinkPermalink 05/14/06 @ 20:50
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
I forgot to say that I liked the article too - I actually identified with it somewhat. Thanks Ellen for pointing out what people often seem to forget. While parenting does not always work out well for all - neither does adoption.

Adoptive parents ARE like everyone else and suspectible to all the same issues that anyone else is - divorce, addictions, death, etc. I know plenty of birth parents at reunion who found that their children's adoptive parents had some or all of those issues/situations.



PermalinkPermalink 05/15/06 @ 00:09
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
Marymartha,

It is very difficult to find reliable statistics about adoption in general, and relinquishing mothers in particular, but I too have heard the same thing that you note: that more surrendering moms are in their 20s or older rather than their teens. However, it is still "expected" that a teen mom will choose adoption, and most people seem to believe that she should do so. That's what I meant by the decision being "unlikely."

I agree that, on its own, "someone to love me" is not a good enough reason for parenting, but sometimes it is not the only reason. Also, plenty of older, married couples have babies for less than solid reasons. We can't say that teen moms are the only ones with cloudy thinking.
PermalinkPermalink 05/15/06 @ 08:34
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
Marymartha wrote:
"You cannot say all adoption is bad and all parenting is good."

No one has said that here.

Marymartha wrote:
"A thirteen year old has no business under ANY circumstances parenting a child. "

Perhaps not in today's world, but it wasn't so long ago that MOST mothers were quite young.

It's just changing social expectations, not an inherent inability of a young woman to parent.
PermalinkPermalink 05/15/06 @ 08:36
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Categories

Misc

Subscribe to Crisis Pregnancy Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 160